Fabric Gift Bags: Are Reusable Christmas Bags Worth It?

Fabric gift bags are worth buying when your family will reuse them each year, because any cloth bag pays off through repeat use. Choose a mixed set of sizes in a plain or winter pattern rather than a dated Santa print. Check the fabric label, and plan a place to keep them between Christmases.

Do fabric gift bags beat wrapping paper?

Fabric gift bags can beat wrapping paper if they keep getting reused, since making a cloth bag has a footprint of its own. EPA’s waste hierarchy puts reuse above recycling: the longer one item stays in use, the less new material you need.

Shopping bag research gives the closest rough guide, though it compares reusable totes with a single plastic bag, not with paper. Popular Science reports a Danish Environmental Protection Agency study of 2018. It found that an organic cotton tote needed 149 uses to match a plastic bag on global warming alone, and about 20,000 once a full set of impacts was counted, a figure driven by a disputed ozone measure. Polyester needed 2 uses for greenhouse gases and 35 across all impacts.

Those numbers are about grocery bags in Denmark, so they don’t transfer exactly. As a rough guide, a cotton bag needs far more uses than a polyester one to pay off, so use it for birthdays too. An unused bag in a closet doesn’t help anyone.

Cotton, recycled polyester or something you already have

Fabric gift bags come in a few common materials, and each one asks for a different kind of commitment.

If you sew, scrap fabric is a clear winner, since it uses what already exists.

Read recycled labels closely. The FTC’s Green Guides say a seller should make an unqualified recycled claim only if the whole product is recycled material, apart from minor incidental parts. Anything less should say how much is recycled.

Reusable fabric Christmas gift bags

Shop fabric Christmas gift bags→

Opens eBay in a new tab. Check condition, seller feedback and returns.

• Drawstring bagsBrowse →
• Cotton bagsBrowse →
• Jute and burlapBrowse →

Which sizes of fabric gift bags to buy

A mixed set of fabric gift bags gets more use than a stack of one size. Before you buy, think about your usual gifts rather than the size names, because a “medium” varies from one maker to the next.

• Small. Jewelry, gift cards, small toys and stocking gifts.
• Medium. Books, candles, boxed games and most mugs.
• Large. Sweaters, bath sets and big picture books.
• Oversized. One or two for toys and the odd bulky present.

Drawstring bags are the fastest to close. For bigger or odd-shaped presents, furoshiki gift wrapping can stretch to almost anything.

Keeping fabric gift bags in circulation

Fabric gift bags work only if they come back, so set up a small habit around them. A plain pattern helps, because a snowy woodland print can stretch into winter birthdays, while a Santa print is out by January.

Try these small steps:

1. Pick one storage spot. Store clean bags with the ornaments so they turn up when you need them.
2. Collect them before cleanup. Have a basket ready when gifts are opened, so nothing goes out with the trash.
3. Wash only as needed. Spot clean instead of running a load, which saves water and wear.
4. Use them all year. Birthdays and hostess gifts add reuses that a Christmas-only bag never gets.

Fabric bags also cut the sorting. Some paper can’t go in the recycling at all, and recyclable wrapping paper explains how to tell. If a mix is more realistic for your home, kraft paper gift wrap can handle whatever the bags don’t.

Fabric bags or other reusable gift wrap?

Fabric bags are the quickest reusable option, but they aren’t the only one. A tin, a basket or a jar can be part of the gift. A cloth wrap folds flat and fits unusual shapes.

Our reusable gift wrap guide compares those options side by side. For the rest of the holiday, eco-friendly Christmas ranks the changes that make the biggest difference.